I love this box building program, but.... ?

Discussion in 'Subwoofer Box and Custom Fabrication' started by Fish Chris, Oct 3, 2008.

  1. Fish Chris

    Fish Chris Full Member

    http://www.reaudio.com/speaker_box/LPort_Box_Calc.html

    but I have one question about it.

    Try punching in a smaller "top depth" measurement, and a longer "bottom depth" (as if you were designing a slanted faced enclosure) {this would be best for my vehicle}
    Now, obviously the vent has a shorter distance at the top, and a longer distance at the bottom. Hmmmm. This seems kind of whacky to me.... like it might mess up the tuning somehow.
    When you read down below, it seems they are measuring the longest distance to give you the total port length... But doesn't air pressure take the path of least resistance (the shorter path) ? ...or is that just electrical current flow ? :)

    Well, I'd assume that somebody has tested this program to confirm the results.....

    Your thoughts ?

    Thank you,
    Fish
     
  2. aznboi3644

    aznboi3644 Full Member

    not accurate...its alright for noobs
     
  3. tyrant1014

    tyrant1014 Full Member

    Yeah, just pay azn a small sum to build one for you. Or buy some of his old stuff he's trying to sell
     
  4. Fish Chris

    Fish Chris Full Member

    Well that's a shame....

    ....because IMPO, this is how a box building program should look / work.

    Of course performance graphs are cool too. But this is the type of program that just makes sense to me.

    Thanks though,
    Fish
     
  5. aznboi3644

    aznboi3644 Full Member

    its not accurate enough for me...it works though.
     
  6. XHiFiX

    XHiFiX Full Member

    Regarding box building programs, between WinISD beta and BassBox Pro 6, which is more accurate?
     
  7. aznboi3644

    aznboi3644 Full Member

    both are good...BassBox has more options...results are very similar. BBP has more tuning options.
     
  8. G3n3R@1

    G3n3R@1 Full Member

    WINISD is pretty easy to get the hang of and i've always had good results.
     
  9. Fish Chris

    Fish Chris Full Member

    Hey aznboi3644.....

    I've been contemplating what you said about the accuracy of the REaudio box builder.....

    I mean, I can see maybe where if ones construction were off just a touch, (like with the square port especially) that it could throw off the predicted results.... maybe a lot.
    But it seems to me that with any of these programs, they should just be following mathematical formulas, which is basically "exact". Of course if the person who set up the box builder made a mistake, it would be wrong.... and probably not "a little wrong" or "inaccuate", but rather, so wrong that it wouldn't even start to work (like to where it would tell you your port should be 339 inches long.... or .039 inches long) and it would be straightened out before ever making it to RE's website.

    I'm not a mathematician, but I know that's all these programs are. Still not sure why this program would not be as accurate as any other. Hmmmm.

    Peace,
    Fish
     
  10. aznboi3644

    aznboi3644 Full Member

    its in the programming...it takes a lot more than you think to write a program